Myth #6: If You Are Feeding Rumen-Protected Methionine You do Not Have to Feed Rumen-Protected Choline

Choline and methionine are both essential nutrients that play critical roles in maintaining healthy liver function, particularly in ruminants. While both are considered lipotropic agents, meaning they help transport fats out of the liver, they serve distinct functions in the body. Choline is a vital component of phosphatidylcholine (PC), which is crucial for the formation of cell membranes and lipoproteins necessary for fat transport. Methionine, on the other hand, provides methyl groups needed for various metabolic processes, including the synthesis of PC from phosphatidylethanolamine. Despite their overlapping roles, they cannot fully substitute for each other, as each performs specific tasks that the other cannot fulfill.

BACKGROUND

In non-ruminant species, research has shown that choline and methionine share a close metabolic relationship. Both are involved in methyl transfer reactions, which are essential for numerous biochemical processes. During the transition period in dairy cows, when the demand for energy and nutrients is high, the liver must process large amounts of fat mobilized from adipose tissue. This can lead to excessive fat accumulation in the liver, resulting in fatty liver syndrome, a common issue during this time. Choline plays a key role in preventing this condition by facilitating the export of fats through the formation of VLDLs. Methionine can also contribute to this process by providing methyl groups necessary for the synthesis of PC. However, the exact extent to which methionine can replace choline remains unclear.

*FIGURE 1

The Role of Choline and Methionine in the Synthesis of Phosphatidylcholine (Figure created by M. deVeth).

BUSTING THE MYTH: FEEDING RUMEN-PROTECTED METHIONINE (RPM) DOES NOT SUBSTITUTE FOR CHOLINE

Recent studies suggest that feeding RPM alone does not eliminate the need for rumen-protected choline (RPC). While methionine can provide methyl groups, it lacks the specific lipotropic properties of choline, which are essential for the efficient transport of fats out of the liver. Research conducted at the University of Florida found that RPC supplementation consistently improved milk production in transition cows, even when diets were already enriched with metabolizable methionine. These findings align with a comprehensive meta-analysis showing an average milk yield increase of 5.2 pounds per day with RPC supplementation. Furthermore, experiments using liver cell cultures demonstrated that choline, but not methionine, significantly enhanced VLDL export, reinforcing the unique role of choline in liver health.

*FIGURE 2

A Summary of Fat-Corrected Milk Yield Responses from Six Studies Evaluating RPC Supplementation (Staples, unpublished).

TAKE-HOME MESSAGE

While methionine is an important nutrient for ruminants, current evidence does not support replacing RPC with RPM in transition cow diets. The assumption that methionine can entirely replace choline is based on observations from non-ruminant studies, which may not fully apply to ruminants. Potential reasons for this discrepancy could include differences in methyl metabolism between species or the need for higher methionine levels to achieve choline-like effects. Over-supplementing methionine can also lead to reduced feed intake and potential toxicity, further complicating its use as a sole substitute for choline. Therefore, it is advisable to continue supplementing RPC alongside RPM to ensure optimal liver health and productivity in transition cows.

Sources

ARDALAN, M., M. DEHGHAN-BANADAKY, K. REZAYAZDI, AND N. GHAVI HOSSEIN-ZADEH. 2010.

The effect of rumen-protected methionine and choline on plasma metabolites of Holstein dairy cows. J. Agric. Sci. doi:10.1017/S0021859610001292.

BERTICS, S. J., AND R. R. GRUMMER. 1999.

Effects of fat and methionine hydroxy analog on prevention and alleviation of fatty liver induced by feed restriction J. Dairy Sci. 82:2731-2736.

CHANDLER, T. L. AND H. M. WHITE. 2017.

Choline and methionine differentially alter methyl carbon metabolism in bovine neonatal hepatocytes. Plos One

ELEK, P., J. R. NEWBOLD, T. GAAL, L. WAGNER, AND F. HUSVETH. 2008.

Effects of rumen-protected choline supplementation on milk production and choline supply of periparturient dairy cows. Anim. 2:1595-1601.

GRUMMER, R. R. 2012.

Choline: A limiting nutrient for transition dairy cows. Proc. Cornell Nutr. Conf.

LIMA, F.S., M.F. SA FILHO, L. F. CRECO, AND J. E. P. SANTOS. 2012.

Effects of feeding rumen-protected choline on incidence of diseases and reproduction in dairy cows. Vet. J. 193:140-145.

OSORIO, J. S., P. JI, J. K. DRACKLEY, D. LUCHINI, AND J. LOOR. 2013.

Supplemental Smartamine M or MetaSmart during the transition period benefits postpartal cow performance and blood neutrophil function. J. Dairy Sci. 96:6248-6263.

PIEPENBRINK, M. S., A. L. MARR, M. R. WALDRON, W. R. BUTLER, T. R. OVERTON, M. VAZQUEZ-ANON, AND M. D. HOLT. 2004.

Feeding 2-hydroxy-4-(methylthio)-butanoic acid to periparturient dairy cows improves milk production but not hepatic metabolism. J. Dairy Sci. 87:1071-1084.

PIEPENBRINK, M. S., AND T. R. OVERTON. 2003.

Liver metabolism and production of cows fed increasing amounts of rumen-protected choline during the periparturient period. J. Dairy Sci. 86:1722-1733.

PREYNAT, A., H. LAPIERRE, M. C. THIVIERGE, M. F. PALIN, N. CARDINAULT, J. J. MATTE, A DESROCHERS, AND C. L. GIRARD. 2010.

Effects of supplementary folic acid and vitamin B12 on hepatic metabolism of dairy cows according to methionine supply. J. Dairy Sci. 93:2130-2142.

SOCHA, M. 1994.

Determining the methionine requirements of lactating dairy cows. Ph.D. Thesis, University of New Hampshire.

ZENOBI, M. G., R. GARDINAL, J. E. ZUNIGA, A. L. G. DIAS, C. D. NELSON, J. P. DRIVER, B. A. BARTON, J. E. P. SANTOS, AND C. R. STAPLES. 2018.

Effects of supplementation with ruminally protected choline on performance of multiparous Holstein cows did not depend upon prepartum caloric intake. J. Dairy Sci. 101:1088-1327.

ZHOU, Z., M. VALILATI-RIBONI, E. TREVISI,J. K. DRACKLEY, D. N. LUCHINI, AND J. J. LOOR. 2016.

Better postpartal performance in dairy cows supplemented with rumen-protected methionine compared with choline during the peripartal period. J. Dairy Sci. 99:8716-8732.

ZOM, R. L. G, J. VAN BAAL, R. M. A. GOSELINK, J. A. BAKKER, M. J. DE VETH, AND A. M. VAN VUUREN. 2011.

Effect of rumen-protected choline on performance, blood metabolites, and hepatic triacylglycerols of periparturient dairy cattle. J. Dairy Sci. 94:4016-4027.